‘Prove it’s safe’: Chorley A&E campaigners concerned about 24-hour reopening
The facility is set to reopen fully for the first time in more than a decade - but some locals are asking at what cost.
Campaigners who have spent more than a decade calling for the return of a 24-hour accident and emergency unit at Chorley and South Ribble Hospital are demanding proof that new plans to make it happen are safe - and will not undermine other health services.
NHS bosses announced on Thursday that the currently part-time facility will be restored to a round-the clock, adults-only operation before the end of next year.
Staff shortages forced the complete closure of the emergency department in April 2016 - before it reopened for 12 hours a day the following January.
Members of a protest group set up at the time of initial closure have gathered at the gates of the Euxton Lane site almost every Saturday morning since - pushing for the exact promise that has now been made.
However, the Protect Chorley and South Ribble Hospital Against Cuts and Privatisation campaign says it only wants to see the full-time A&E service reinstated if it can be done so safely - and claimed the NHS had done nothing to demonstrate that was the case.


The group also said there had been no “transparency” about where the money to fund the extended hours will come from within an already stretched system - sparking fears that the move will result in health leaders “taking from Peter to pay Paul”.
Founding member Jenny Hurley told the Lancashire Post the campaign had sought details of safe staffing levels for a 24/7 operation - and the additional workforce needed to achieve them.
However, she said freedom of information requests - submitted since the government suggested in the Commons back in July that a full-time Chorley A&E may once again be feasible - have been refused.
“I was in hospital for a procedure recently and there was a little chart on a whiteboard that showed what the recommended staff [numbers were] for the ward - and it then said what they'd actually got that day.
“This information is given continuously - it’s nothing that shouldn't be known. And in the case of Chorley A&E, these are not trivial questions [when] staffing shortages were the reason the service closed in the first place,” Jenny said.
The NHS has been required to publish the safe - and actual - levels of nursing and midwifery staff on inpatient wards since 2014.
The nine-month full shutdown of Chorley A&E which began in April 2016 was the result of a chronic shortage of middle-grade doctors at the facility - with six of the then 14 required posts being unfilled.
In announcing the extended opening hours, Lancashire Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (LTH) - which runs Chorley and South Ribble Hospital - said it was confident the longstanding “fragility” surrounding the available workforce to staff a round-the-clock A&E could now be overcome.
The organisation added that the “detailed planning” needed to do so would now begin - and stressed that the work would have “clinical safety [and] affordability” at its heart.
However, campaigners also have concerns about what the latter part of that pledge means in practice.
The Lancashire and South Cumbria Integrated Care Board (ICB) - which is responsible for commissioning services for patients across the sub-region - has said it will include a 24-hour service at Chorley A&E in its spending plans for 2027/28.
But the finances of the organisation are already under significant pressure. A report presented to an ICB meeting earlier this month shows that it has to make £221m in “cost mitigation” savings during the current financial year.
However, even with that target, the aim is not to break even, but to achieve an agreed end-of-year deficit of £34.9m, which will then attract “support funding” from NHS England.
The report noted a so-called “delivery risk” - or forecast shortfall - in the savings plans at the halfway point in 2026/27 of £24.4m. That means “further mitigation and focus” will be required through to the end of March, it warned.
Against that challenging backdrop, Jenny Hurley believes there is a risk other services could suffer as a result of Chorley A&E’s full restoration - and the campaign group wants evidence to disprove that theory.
“The ICB is always talking about the ‘difficult decisions’ it will have to make to balance its books,” Jenny said.
“Taking from Peter to pay Paul is not a sustainable healthcare strategy - and it should not be dressed up as progress. And who is Peter [going to be] in this instance?
“The people of Chorley deserve reassurance that this service is being expanded with new investment - not by diverting resources from elsewhere.
“Plus, the support services for A&E - things like radiology - will also have to be safely staffed around the clock.
“The fact that transparency has been repeatedly withheld, legitimate questions on safety have gone unanswered and that political voices appear louder than clinical ones does not inspire confidence.”
Asked by the Post whether the campaign group would rather the 12-hour status quo was maintained if their fears over the impact of a return to 24-hour opening could not be allayed, Jenny said: “If having one service is safer than not having another, then we get that.
“We don't agree with it - we think it should all be funded [to the necessary level] - but that's a higher political [question].”
The ICB told the Post on Thursday that the full-time A&E would largely be funded via the national tariff paid for emergency care. That is an agreed upfront payment based on expected annual patient treatments in emergency department facilities.
If actual patient numbers are ultimately higher or lower than the agreed plan, the payment adjusts in the corresponding direction, based on a percentage of the published per-patient ‘unit price’ for A&E activity.
Until the 24-hour service at Chorley A&E returns, the department will continue to operate between 8am and 8pm, seven days a week.
There will be no change to the neighbouring urgent care centre on the site - which treats both adults and children with minor complaints - either before or after the emergency department extends its hours.
What does the NHS say about campaigners’ concerns?
In response to the safety and financial questions raised by the Protect Chorley and South Ribble Hospital Against Cuts and Privatisation campaign, an NHS spokesperson for both LTH and the ICB said:
“Whilst we have been delighted with the overwhelmingly positive response to the news that work is now progressing towards restoring [a] 24/7, adult Type 1 emergency department…both the trust and the commissioners have been very clear that there is a lot more detailed planning, financial and workforce recruitment activity required to extend the service safely and sustainably.
“This is currently under way and clearly we won’t be in a position to answer all the questions that people may have until this work is completed.
“All NHS organisations have a responsibility to balance risks and financial priorities within the formal framework of our board structures - and we will go through all the appropriate assurances before the 24/7 service commences.
“We agree with the campaigners that we must have the right staffing in place before we extend the opening hours which is why no opening date has been agreed at this stage – this will take as long as it takes.
“However, the NHS never stands still, things have moved on in recent years and we are confident that in the coming months we will be able to attract sufficient high-quality candidates to enable the extended service to be put in place.”
On the specific issue of funding for the expanded service, Professor Craig Harris, chief commissioning officer for the ICB, added: “The reduction in opening hours was only ever a temporary measure, so restoring 24/7 opening as soon as safe staffing levels could be attained was always planned for.
“Funding will be managed through our existing budgets and contractual arrangements. Including this within the ICB’s commissioning intentions means planning for it within our approved budget for the next financial year, 2027/28.
“As part of that process, we will consider potential safety and quality impacts across services and how best to use our overall resources to meet the needs of people across Lancashire and South Cumbria.
“Much of the increased cost of providing round-the-clock adult Type 1 emergency department opening hours at Chorley and South Ribble Hospital will be mitigated by the reduction in demand for the same services at Royal Preston Hospital and other provision.”