Preston North End's academy: A colossal challenge as three more leave including Felipe
A handful of young players have left PNE upon the expiry of their contracts
Preston North End’s retained list was a reminder of one of the club’s hardest challenges over the past decade. The gap from academy to first team remains a colossal gap to bridge; an almighty jump from the EFL Youth Alliance League to the Championship.


James Pradic, Noah Mawene and Felipe became the latest three to leave, with the post-academy period resembling somewhat of a footballing black hole. The trio all had hype around them at various stages but it wasn’t to be.
Speaking in May 2022, CEO Peter Ridsdale said: "Sitting here today we don’t have a professional goalkeeper, although we have a very good one in the academy who I hope will break through, and stop us having to resort to the loan market in a few years.”
Two years ago, ex-boss Ryan Lowe said of Mawene: “He’s a top kid, a top prospect and he’s probably going to play - and captain - Preston North End in years to come. He’s got the right attitude and everything that goes with that.”
People will form their own judgements on the weight of those respective comments, but there was clearly some belief. Josh Seary - handed a pro-deal before he’d even turned 17 - was another one tipped to break through in the future.
Felipe was an interesting one. Ever since his five goals in the 2022/23 FA Youth Cup there was a fixation, and his finishing ability was clear to see. But, whether it was manager Paul Heckingbottom, Ridsdale or Lowe, the buzz was never drummed up too much.
Nonetheless, he was one of few youngsters to go out on loan (his first) and score some goals - seven in the National League North for AFC Fylde. Nineteen isn’t young in this day and age but it is in Preston’s context, and yet the journey with Felipe ends there.
The one true academy success story of the last 10+ years at PNE remains Ben Davies, someone who went out on loan five times in the space of three years before forging his way into the Preston side: L2, L2, back down to the National League, L2 and then L1.
There is an argument that if players cannot make an impact at a certain level - such as the Northern Premier League - then it is best to move on. There is also gut feel. On the flip side, players may simply need more time and opportunity.
Straight out of category three academy football, the task of loaning youngsters out to a solid, senior level cannot be easy at all. Clubs lower down the pyramid operate seriously and have their own ambitions - they do not owe Preston anything.
PNE got Mawene out to Newport and Southend; Lewis Leigh to Crewe and Bromley. Players have gone to Fylde, Altrincham, Macclesfield, Ross County, Cork City, Chorley, Galway United, Southport, Chester, Marine.
Those aren’t poor platforms to be given to 18/19-year-olds coming out of cat-three. It may well be that the quality of player just isn’t there, but to expect a first team ready player within two years seems unrealistic - particularly given the jump in level.
That isn’t the only method of success, though. One thing to celebrate could be the sales of players to lower league clubs, if they’ve impressed at National League level for example. Unfortunately, that hasn’t really happened.
Of course, Preston did cash in on Theo Mawene last summer. That raises a separate point all in itself, though. Mawene stood out in a FA Youth Cup tie against Liverpool and was hoovered up by Brentford that summer, having played 11 first team minutes for PNE.
‘A brutal system’
Speaking recently, Wolves’ technical director Matt Jackson said: “The academy system in this country is set up to channel the best players to the biggest football clubs, and we can do nothing about it.
"Last week, we received demands (over) one of our under 16 players from an agent. We have a decision to make on that agent walking that player out of our football club, (whether) we invest about two million pounds in salary and an agent's fee of £300,000 - to retain a player we've had in our academy for a long time.
"And that player can just walk out; we have no power to do it. We have an outstanding young goalkeeper in our academy at the moment and we resisted offers from the biggest clubs last summer, because we could at the stage of the cycle he's at with us in the academy. We expect to lose him this summer and we can't prevent it.
“So, we produce quality players and we have young internationals in our squads, but the system at the moment - certainly following Brexit - it's become incredibly cutthroat in having to retain those players. It's given us a dilemma where millions of pounds are committed to 16-year-olds, or they walk out on us. It's a brutal system."
That is the bleak, bigger picture at play, with the struggles of a category-one academy outlined by Jackson. Ridsdale has spoken about a couple of scenarios at Preston, where players they had high hopes for - pre-scholarship - have just been swept away by the big boys. Assistant boss Stuart McCall recently highlighted the challenge presented by North End’s location as a club.
“Of course, yeah,” he told BBC Lancashire, when asked if they’d like to bring more players through the system. “But I think at Preston, there's such a small catchment area - all the sides around here... But whoever it may be, if they're good enough, they're always old enough for me, always.
“We've always blooded, myself and Paul. If you're good enough, you'll play. There's one or two but when they go out on loan, they've also got to make an impact. A few of our lads have gone out and when they’ve come up in men's football, they’ve found it a little bit difficult. So, they need that little step, they need to go and play their games.
“It's totally different playing academy football, reserve team football to an extent. Kitt (Nelson) did well-ish over in Ireland, but he's come back and he's just not been able to take that next step yet. Young Theo Carroll's been injured. So listen, every manager would love academy players to come through, without a doubt.
“But obviously, they've got to be good enough. I don't think there's any problem with the guys that are in charge of it. It's getting the players earlier and getting them in. As I say, it's an area where there's lots of football clubs around. It's actually scouting them young to start with and getting them in.
“First and foremost, getting them into Preston at an early age. And then hopefully, later down the line you see the fruits of it. I think all clubs have that problem when you're in an area and there's a lot of different clubs fighting for (players). But higher the category, then hopefully the better quality of player.”
Heckingbottom has pulled no punches over the strides required of the academy. Like with the first team there is a major onus on strong recruitment - a vacancy this week for a lead academy scout in Manchester represents a small step in the right direction. Under new squad cost ratio financial rules, academy spend will remain unpunished. Therefore, any takeover and increased resource - as referenced by the PNE boss - could also bode well.
“Every penny's gone into the first-team squad and keeping them in the Championship,” said Heckingbottom last month. “There's not a separate amount of money for the academy... it's not a bottomless pit. In an ideal world you want to generate, create, coach and produce the best possible players. Getting them in the first team would be brilliant but that's a long, long way off. I don't know the plans of any potential new owners in that respect.”
When there is one pot of cash for everything and millions are lost per year, money being directed towards the first team is no surprise. There are then things like the Deepdale pitch, which is finally being fixed this summer. But, when there is a backdrop of staleness and poor record of player trading, a thriving academy system would be something to celebrate and buy into. Edwards’ comments are alarming but not a reason to give up or lower ambitions. ‘He’s one of our own’ has to be one of the proudest chants a football supporter can sing. Hope remains that, one day, it will be heard around Deepdale again.