'This is the one thing we think should happen to Preston bus gate fines', city businesses say

Business leaders have called for the cash raised from ‘bus gate’ fines issued in Preston to stay in the city – and be spent on improving its roads.

The notorious bus-only zones can rake in huge sums for Lancashire County Council – with the most recently-introduced restriction, on Corporation Street, generating £3.3m in the space of just 18 months.

The authority says it invests the proceeds from the penalty charge notices (PCNs) handed out to motorists – for going beyond the points that prohibited vehicles must not pass – in maintaining and upgrading the highway network.

However, that money can be used on improvement projects anywhere in the county council’s patch – and across any of the 4,600 miles of road for which it is responsible.

The bus gate on Corporation Street has been a big source of income for Lancashire County Council - but where was the money spent?placeholder image
The bus gate on Corporation Street has been a big source of income for Lancashire County Council - but where was the money spent?

Now, the Preston Business Improvement District (BID) and the North and Western Chamber of Commerce have written to County Hall to request that at least a proportion of PCN revenue generated by Preston’s eight bus gates is retained in the city.

The organisations say businesses have expressed “concerns” over the fines – and urged the highways authority to invest some of the income derived from drivers in the city “directly into improvements within Preston”.

Their letter adds: “We recognise that Preston’s road network, especially in the city centre, is in need of significant upgrades. The Fishergate project, for example, has not yet delivered the expected improvements and many arterial roads are in poor condition.”

The two groups also demand “transparency” over where the fines cash is currently spent – and details of any “tangible benefits” being felt by Preston.

Motorists who breach the rules are issued with a £70 PCN, which is reduced to £35 if paid within 21 days.

The amount of money generated from bus gates in Preston is often sustained at a high level for years after their introduction. For instance, in 2023, the restriction in operation on Fishergate in the city centre, between Mount Street and Corporation Street, was flouted almost 8,800 times – seven years after it was first installed and following a blaze of publicity about how many drivers were falling foul of it when it was first introduced.

As the Lancashire Post revealed in December, the bus gate put in place on Corporation Street, between Marsh Lane and Heatley Street, had been breached on more than 100,000 occasions since enforcement began in June 2024 – raising £3.35m in fines.

Last year, Preston City Council formally called for the suspension of that bus gate site so that a “full reassessment” of the scheme could be carried out.

The authority also urged the county council to put the brakes on a bus lane – the ninth bus-only stretch of road in Preston – planned for New Hall Lane. However, enforcement of that restriction, on the city-bound side of the route, between Fishwick Road and Witton Street, came into effect earlier this week – and the Corporation Street set-up remains in operation.

At a Preston City Council meeting last week, St. Matthew’s ward councillor Suleman Sarwar – who has led a campaign against the New Hall Lane bus lane – said he believed it was “motivated by greed”. He added that it was important to “keep the pressure on” County Hall over both schemes.

City council leader Matthew Brown said that while it was necessary to “support public transport”, the time had come to consider “how we can do this differently”.

Meanwhile, Ingol and Cottam ward representative Ben Ward said he had requested, via a Freedom of Information submission, exactly the data that BID and the Chamber have since sought about where in Lancashire Preston-generated PCN money is being spent. He said he was told the county council has “no idea where it goes”, because it is put into the general transport funding pot.

Cllr Ward said he had also asked whether the authority tracked where the people being fined in Preston actually lived, but was advised that the information was not retained. He said he feared that the bus gates were giving Preston a bad name beyond its borders - especially amongst visitors.

“When they go through the bus gate and get an unexpected fine, I suspect they don’t come back – I suspect it puts them off considerably,” Cllr Ward said.

Responding to the issues raised by the business groups, County Cllr Warren Goldsworthy, cabinet member for highways and transport at Lancashire County Council, said: "Bus lanes and gates across the county provide an essential traffic management function, providing priority to buses, safer routes for cycles and links for taxis and providing essential transport links for customers.

"Any surplus income is reinvested in the county's highways budget where it is used to benefit all the residents of Lancashire through highway improvements."Money is not ringfenced to specific areas because as the highway authority, we have a duty to prioritise areas of greatest need, so sometimes this will be within Preston and sometimes it won't.

"Lancashire's roads support more than 4.6 million journeys every day and maintaining over 4,000 miles of road is a huge challenge. We repair around 3,400 potholes per month on Lancashire's roads. To address the backlog alone it would require upwards of £650m."

COMPROMISE CALL

Preston BID and the Chamber of Commerce say in their letter to Lancashire County Council that while they accept bus gates are now a “permanent feature of the city’s traffic management strategy”, there are some potential “solutions” to the problem of drivers inadvertently straying into sections of road from which their vehicles are banned. They suggest:

***limiting operating hours

“Since buses do not operate 24/7, restricting the bus gate hours could reduce unnecessary fines and benefit the city’s night time economy.”

***implementing warning notices

“First-time offenders should receive a warning letter, informing them of their infringement and that future violations will incur a fine.”

***improving signage

“Signs should be clearer and more visible, similar to successful approaches used in other cities, to ensure drivers are adequately warned before entering restricted areas.”

County Cllr Goldworthy said: "All of our bus gates/lanes are clearly signed and receive regular publicity in the press thanks to articles like this. We continually review the sites [and] welcome the recognition from the Chamber of Commerce that our signs are legally compliant. However we will not be seeking to provide any more warning notices."

Note - this article was updated on 5th February to include comment received from Lancashire County Council.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1886
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice