Major update on derelict Preston pub facing demolition as council reveals 'dilemma'

A question mark appears to have been placed over plans to completely demolish a historic Preston pub that has been closed for almost a decade after a senior councillor said a final decision has not yet been taken.

The fate of The Tithebarn, opposite the bus station, looked to have been sealed last month when Preston City Council secured permission from its own independent planning committee to flatten the former hostelry.

That followed a survey undertaken on behalf of the authority which concluded that the building was “unstable and unsafe” – with even remedial work being deemed too dangerous to be carried out at the site.

The assessment seemed to have put paid to the hope that the least decayed part of the late 18th century premises – whose doors closed for good in February 2016 – might be able to be spared.

The Tithebarn looked set for complete demolition - but is there still a possibility part of it could remain standing?placeholder image
The Tithebarn looked set for complete demolition - but is there still a possibility part of it could remain standing? | National World

The Preserving Preston’s Heritage Group (PPH) group had earlier this year persuaded the city authority to investigate the possibility of retaining the Lord Street-facing aspect of the property, with only a one-time barn area – on Tithebarn Street – needing to be bulldozed. Their aim was that the section that remained standing could become a heritage centre for the city – an ambition that appeared to have been dashed with November’s planning decision.

However, at the city authority’s latest full council meeting, deputy leader Martyn Rawlinson – who last month spoke of the “public safety” risk posed by the building – said the council faced “a real dilemma”.

One of the 'bulging' external walls of the former Tithebarn pub - just feet from the almost complete Vault Youth Zoneplaceholder image
One of the 'bulging' external walls of the former Tithebarn pub - just feet from the almost complete Vault Youth Zone | Davis Consultants

Responding to a question from planning committee member Cllr Daniel Guise about when the bulldozers were set to roll in – given the safety concerns surrounding the building – Cllr Rawlinson said: “Having planning permission to do something doesn’t necessarily mean it’s going to happen that way.

“We went for that [option] because of the structural surveys that suggest it needs to be completely demolished, despite us wanting to try and save it in some form.”

He noted that, regardless of the planning permission, the cabinet had delegated the ultimate decision about partial or complete demolition to the council’s director of environment and property, in consultation with him.

Cllr Rawlinson said he had requested “costings” for “shoring up a small part” of the building – which had been estimated at £150,000.

He explained: “That was just [for the] ground floor external walling – mainly because of the cellars. The wooden floor is rotten, [so] the struts would have to go down into the cellars – it’s a big job.

“And then it just makes the rest of the job harder as well, because you’re working around that – so if we wanted to save even more of it, the cost would rise.

“I don’t see a lot of appetite amongst members to spend an awful lot of money on this building. So it’s actually a really difficult decision; I wanted to save it as much as anyone – it’s a very old building with a lot of history.

“The final decision has not been taken – the costs are a real barrier, as is the fact that [the council is set to be abolished by 2028 under a government-ordered shake-up] – and we have lots of big projects on the go that we’re desperate to get over the line before [then]”.

However, Glenn Cookson, from PPH, said the group took little comfort from the injection of uncertainty into what had appeared to be a done deal.

“It’s clear that Preston City Council still has no transparent plan for the future of The Tithebarn – or is choosing not to share it. Given the level of public attention the building has received in recent months, it’s surprising that the council has not addressed the issue decisively or clearly updated residents.

“Instead, it appears the demolition is being delayed until the last possible moment, limiting meaningful public scrutiny.

“The council has owned The Tithebarn for decades – and its current condition is the result of prolonged neglect. Given that this is potentially the oldest building in Preston, it is difficult to accept claims that the building is valued or cared for when the council’s own inaction has allowed it to become the eyesore and safety risk it now describes.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1886
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice