Everything Preston North End CEO Peter Ridsdale said about Milutin Osmajic ban during 10-minute talkSPORT interview

PNE CEO Peter Ridsdale appeared on talkSPORT on Tuesday to speak about the nine-match ban imposed on striker Milutin Osmajic

Preston North End chief executive Peter Ridsdale appeared on talkSPORT on Tuesday morning to discuss the nine-match ban imposed on striker Milutin Osmajic after he was last week found guIlty of racially abusing Burnley midfielder Hannibal Mejbri.

The incident happened during the Lilywhites’ goalless draw with the Clarets in February. The Montenegro international striker will now miss up to and including North End’s game against Stoke City on Boxing Day. He has also been fined £21,000.

Osmajic has always strongly refuted and denied the allegations. Now Ridsdale has spoken on the decision that was made by an independent regulatory commission.

Speaking on the White & Jordan, alongside Jim White and Simon Jordan, he emphasised his disappointment that Osmajic had been sanctioned on the 'balance of probabilities' rather than 'beyond reasonable doubt' .

Here’s a transcript of that conversation, that can also be watched here.

What was said as Peter Ridsdale appeared on talkSPORT

White: So Peter, tell me, it's the wording that you are honing in on, are you not? We know that the outcome was determined on the balance of probabilities rather than one that is beyond reasonable doubt, am I right?

Ridsdale: Well it's the principle, Jim, it's not just the wording on this occasion.

You know we live in a society where we accept totally, and I grew up believing you're either not guilty or you were guilty of something, and to be guilty you had to be found guilty beyond reasonable doubt, otherwise you know it was innocent until proven guilty. But on this occasion I sat through the two days of the tribunal, I also sat through when the FA investigated earlier, before that with talking to Miutin, and the reality is there's only one person who knows what was said and that was Milutin.

There's then a second person who thinks he knows what was said, which was Hannibal, who had his back to Milutin in a crowd of 21,000 in a local derby, a lot of noise, so nobody's suggesting Hannibal isn't saying what he thought he heard. But what we're saying is there's only one person who knows, and the two-day tribunal used lip readers who said they couldn't be certain of what was said, and the FA have said on balance of probability we think he probably said a word which included reference to race or colour.

Our concern is, and you know, you're spending time talking about it today, of something of this severity, to determine it was on the balance of probability i.e the suggestion is we are guessing of what might have been said, we find that dangerous.

Jordan: Did you know the terms of reference prior to going into the hearing, Peter? Did you know that it was going to be adjudicated based upon those sort of parameters prior to the hearing being heard?

Ridsdale: We were told there were three potential outcomes Simon. One is not proven; two is beyond reasonable doubt; and three, balance of probabilities. So clearly the FA set the terms, we don't because it's apparently section 8 of the FA handbook, and clearly we can't influence that. But having sat through the two days, having obviously spoken to Milutin, and this happened nine months ago, this took nine months to get to a conclusion, for somebody to say that there was no independent verification of what was said, there was nobody else on either team, that none of the officials heard what was said, there were two people - one of whom said something clearly and there's one of whom heard something who had his back to the person who was talking.

White: But, Peter, with respect, why would Burnley's Hannibal Mejbri say that he was racially abused when in actual fact he hadn't been?

Ridsdale: Well, you have to ask him that and, you know, we’re getting into individual cases. The word that Milutin consistently since the second that the game finished, and he was asked by the officials what he said, sounds like the word that Hannibal accused him of saying. But it was a different word, and all I'm saying is, on the balance of probabilities, for something of this severity surely, whether it be on this occasion or any future occasions, I think that when something is this serious, you have to be in a position where it's either proven beyond reasonable doubt or not proven.

White: I've known you for years and I stress I'm really pleased that you took our invitation to come on live, but can you tell us this morning that Osmajic - presumably you were one-to-one with him in your office - when you looked in his eyes and said: “Did you say this?” and he strongly denied that he said it. Do you believe him?

Ridsdale: I do and the other thing, Jim, that I will stress is from the second the game finished nine months ago, and of course I work with him every day, not once has he changed his version of events of what he said, not once.

White: I suppose because he's got to stick to his story, hasn't he?

Ridsdale: No, not necessarily, because he understood the severity and the fact is, when he was accused of biting, which you referred to earlier, he admitted it, he knew he’d done wrong, he accepted he’d done wrong. He genuinely does not believe he's done anything wrong.

To that degree, we have said we support the player and I'm not suggesting Hannibal is accusing him of something that he didn't think he said, because Hannibal had his back to him in a crowd that was screaming and shouting. All I'm saying is, where there's no independent verification of what was said, including lip readers who couldn't tell, to then say on the balance of probability we think he probably made reference to one word that Milutin has said he hasn't said, is a dangerous precedent - that's what we're saying.

Jordan: Two things, Peter. Do you think he was subjected to a preconceived bias because, ultimately, he's put himself in front of them previously for bad behavior? And do you think that the rules in of themselves, because you guys are part of allowing these rules to exist and this governance to exist, do you think that the rules in of themselves governing disciplinary panels need to be changed so that it only accepts beyond reasonable doubt?

Ridsdale: Well, I think on the first one you're inviting me to almost get an FA charge myself, so I've got to stand one step back and say that, in my view, having sat through the two days, had this been beyond reasonable doubt, I don't think any fair-minded people could find him guilty. The fact that you have the option of balance of probability, which means to some extent you are guessing, I think is dangerous in severe cases.

Jordan: Why is it there, Peter? Why is it there then? if it's dangerous and it's very subjective, why is it there?

Ridsdale: Well, I don't know. I mean, you need to ask the FA.

Jordan: But you're involved in the game, Peter. You can ask the FA that and, as an experienced operator, you've been around long enough so you can answer without putting yourself in a way of a charge and you can have an opinion.

Ridsdale: Well, I can certainly answer the second question you just asked which is: do I believe the rules are wrong? Yes, I do, and in fact we as a club are going to write to the FA - we've already spoken to the EFL - and lobby for a change, where anything of this nature ought to be either not proven or proven beyond reasonable doubt.

White: How do you do that? You want it to be beyond reasonable doubt, how do you get to that? You'd have to mike-up players wouldn't you?

Ridsdale: Jim, if you were in a court of law on any criminal case, they are the only two potential outcomes.

White: But this is not a court of law. It's a totally different environment.

Jordan: But Jim, it has to be held to the highest standard because this player now, for all intents and purposes, (is a) racist and will suffer from that for the rest of his career, irrespective whether he did or didn't do it.

Jordan: Are you going to appeal, Peter? Is there an appeal process available to you?

Ridsdale: Well, we are waiting for the written reasons to come in, albeit I've seen what the tribunal published last week to us before the sentence. We will have a look on that appeal. I'm told at the moment that unfortunately the appeal could only be a procedural appeal, but as soon as we get it we will have a look at it. But we are very dissatisfied with the process which allows, for what we believe, to be essentially an ability to guess and this is very serious. And as you just pointed out, Milutin’s reputation, if he said it and if we believed he said it, we would be the first to be throwing the book at him because we're very proud of our policies as a football club.

However, on the evidence I've seen, I don't believe, on a normal basis of deciding on guilt or innocence, that balance of probability is correct in this case.

White: Peter, finally as I said in the introduction, Osmajic was banned for eight matches and fined £15,00 for biting a Blackburn defender…. does it not come to a stage, Peter, with all due respect, where you look at the player and you think, is this worth all the hassle?

Ridsdale: Well, I think every individual, whoever they are, deserves to be treated fairly and properly. In this case with Hannibal, with Milutin saying he didn't say the words he's been accused of saying, in the previous case he admitted doing it and the nine matches were because they took into account his previous discipline record of eight matches, that's why he got nine on this occasion.

Jordan: If he didn't say this, Jim, if I were a player, I would be suing the authorities for defamation. If this sort of governance seeps into our society, the challenges that we will have in life will be absolutely unbelievable, and why shouldn't he be expecting the same level of governance and opportunity to be able to prove himself, innocent or guilty, of a very serious charge.

It's one of the most significant things in our society now about culture wars and the battle of ethnicities and racism and all that goes with it, and so with that in mind, if you're now called a racist and you want a badge with that, you've got to live with that whether you did it or didn't do it. In this instance, didn't do it. What are you supposed to do about it? Just get on with it on the balance of probabilities. Surely you've got to prove it beyond all reasonable doubt, not because someone thinks they heard something and it might have been misinterpreted.

News you can trust since 1886
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice