'Inexcusable' - family of Preston dementia patient who died after care home assault launch civil case
The family of a man who suffered a fatal brain bleed after being attacked in his Preston care home have launched a civil case over his death.
The Post revealed on Friday that 70-year-old John Alston died after being punched in the face by a “significantly younger man” who had been inappropriately placed in Hulton House, Fulwood, with him.
Lancashire Coroner Kate Bissett has now written a Prevention of Future Deaths Report, asking NHS England to address her worries that future death could occur if there is a repeat of confusion over which Integrated Care Board is responsible for the placement of residents, and there are delays and a lack of information as a result.
Now Mr Alston’s family have expressed their upset over the circumstances leading to his death in 2022, as they rememember him as “a wonderful man” and “the best of us”.
A criminal case was ruled out, but the family are now persuing a civil claim over the matters.
His son Ryan said: “My dad was a much loved man by all who knew him. He was selfless, funny and kind and would do anything for us. As his children, we will be forever grateful that we had him as our father and my mother feels very fortunate that she called him her husband.
“And, recently, three years after his death, the grief had started to soften, and our memories were beginning to be happy ones filled with his smile and laughter. That has now changed. The inquest forced us to confront in painful detail what our father went through and how badly he was failed when he was at his most vulnerable. It has brought back overwhelming feelings of anger and devastation that we thought we were beginning to heal from.


“It was heartbreaking to have to make the decision to place him in the home but we just couldn’t keep him or my mum safe. It was deeply distressing to see how his most basic needs were consistently not met by Hulton House as we had to constantly chase them to feed him the correct food, clean him and make sure he was in the correct clothes. However, this was nothing compared to the feelings we felt when we heard about him being attacked and hurt and eventually killed. To sit through that and then find out his death was avoidable was very distressing.”
Ryan said it was “devastating” to hear that there has been confusion over the discharge of the younger man and which ICB was responsible for his placement, adding: “then to hear that Hulton House didn’t follow my father’s care plan to protect him from this resident on the night of the fatal assault was crushing. These failures are inexcusable.”
He added: “We want to be clear that we have no animosity towards (the man who punched him) and have never blamed him for killing our father. He was another vulnerable man who was failed by the same institutions.
“My dad was the best of us, he really was. It was heartbreaking that as the disease progressed we couldn’t look after him the way he always looked after us. We had no choice but to hand that care over the specialists who could look after him. We now have to live with the fact that that decision to hand him over to Hulton House resulted in his tragic death, something nobody deserved, certainly not the wonderful man that was my father.”
Hulton House
LM Healthcare which runs Hulton House, said: ‘We believe the Coroner took full cognisance of all relevant facts and made his report accordingly. This is now available for the public to review in detail. Our thoughts remain very much with the families of those involved.’
NHS England was approached for comment last week and has not responded.