Why Preston's 'ban' on new HMOs might not block them all

Not all new bedsit-style developments in Preston will require planning permission in future – in spite of a proposed policy change designed to ensure that they do.

Preston City Council’s cabinet agreed in August to introduce new rules that would mean the conversion of properties in urban areas into so-called ‘houses of multiple occupation’ (HMOs) would first have to be given the green light by the authority – regardless of their size.

The move was bound up with a separate plan to effectively ban the creation of any more HMOs – or house shares, as they are also known – in Preston’s built-up core, where more than 900 of them already exist.

However, following a High Court ruling in September – involving a different local authority – Preston’s cabinet members have now been advised that some small HMO conversions will still be able to go ahead without planning permission, irrespective of any new regulations introduced by the council.

The deciding factor will be whether the alterations to the properties are considered “material” changes of use under planning law – a distinction that will also affect the broader aim of blocking further HMO development in urban parts of the city.

HMOs are properties in which three or more people from different households live together and share amenities like the kitchen and bathroom.

National planning rules mean only those proposed HMOs that would have seven or more bedrooms need the green light from local councils – with smaller-scale facilities being classed automatically as ‘permitted development’.

Preston has enacted an opt out from that arrangement since 2012 by insisting on formal approval for all sizes of house share in the neighbourhoods where they are most common – specifically, most of Plungington and parts of the Frenchwood and Fishwick, City Centre, Deepdale and Ashton wards.

The cabinet decision in August approved extending the area covered by that requirement – known as an ‘Article 4 direction’ – across all of urban Preston, amid concerns about what the city council said was the potential impact of HMOs on the “quality of life” in those places where there is a proliferation of them.

The move meant that permission would eventually be needed for all HMOs in an area bounded by the M55 in the north, Edith Rigby Way in the west, the M6 in the east and the River Ribble in the south – along with the approved Bartle Garden Village development.

Meanwhile, a policy proposed within the new Central Lancashire Local Plan (CLLP) would lead to an effective ban on new or expanded HMOs in that same urban patch – with the starting point for any such proposals in that location being the refusal of permission.

As the Local Democracy Reporting Service has previously revealed, it is understood that “exceptional need” would have to be demonstrated in order for a new or enlarged house share development to be approved once the CLLP – which is currently being examined by government inspectors in public hearings – comes into force, which is expected to be in late 2026.

The legal position on Article 4 directions has not changed since the city council’s cabinet made its decision in August on extending the one already in place in Preston. However, the High Court case on which members were briefed during a meeting before Christmas stressed that councillors making any decisions on Article 4 directions must understand that “there may be instances where [such directions] do not apply”.

A cabinet report stated: “To require planning permission, the change of use must be a material change…having land use implications.”

Members were told, by way of an example, that the conversion of “a family dwellinghouse to a small HMO” may not cross that threshold. “That will be a matter for the local planning authority to determine on a case-by-case basis,” the report added.

The clarification demonstrates that the city council will still not be able to demand that all HMO developments receive planning permission before they can go ahead. That has a knock-on effect on the proposed CLLP policy of default refusal of HMOs in urban Preston – because some might not require an application to be submitted for the change in the first place.

Cabinet members were also told that there would be financial risk to the authority if they sought to shorten the notice period for the introduction of the new Article 4 direction from the 12 months that was recommended in August.

They were advised that other local authorities that have given less than a year’s notice of such a change have had to pay compensation claims of over £100,000 to landlords because of the potential drop in the value of their properties as a result of implementing new Article 4 measures. Preston’s formal notice period is yet to begin.

HMO PROBLEMS

The number of HMOs in Preston has ballooned in recent years, with 214 being added to the council-held register between 2021 and 2023. As of November 2024, the overall tally stood at 917 – none of which were in the Preston Rural North or Preston Rural East wards.

The highest concentration of HMOs was, at that point, found in the City Centre ward, where there were 311 – almost double that in the area with the second largest number, Plungington, which had 157. Significant numbers were also located in Deepdale (87), Cadley, (76) and Greyfriars (69)

A review of the HMO landscape in Preston undertaken by Preston City Council early in 2025 found that concentrations of such properties can affect:

***pressures on and challenges to council services;

***deprivation, housing quality and overcrowding;

***crime rates and fear of safety;

***quality of support and services given by [housing] providers

***visual and environmental health impacts on conservation areas;

***rough sleepers and homelessness

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1886
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice