I had my own business and home – then I made a mistake and everything went wrong

A Ribble Valley councillor gave an emotional speech about losing her home and needing a Clitheroe emergency shelter, in a debate about council tax and housing help.

Labour Coun Rachael Ray highlighted the Joiners Arms, a former pub turned into emergency accommodation, which has been allocated a £250,000 upgrade in Ribble Valley Council’ new budget.

While political parties agree some money should be spent on it, they disagreed over how much. Labour said the building deserves more and, separately, more council money should be spent on affordable housing too.

The former Joiners Arms pub in Clitheroeplaceholder image
The former Joiners Arms pub in Clitheroe | Google/LDRS

Labour wanted to raise Ribble Valley’s council tax – but ruling Conservatives won a vote to freeze it. This will be the second year that it is frozen. Conservatives said the council has enough money for its plans.

But Coun Ray said: “Sixteen years ago, I had my own business and home. But I made a business mistake and everything went wrong. I ended-up at the Joiner’s Arms. I’m one of these poor people we’re talking about regarding emergency housing. If we can make that accommodation feel more like home, rather than one-up from a cardboard box, I would happily do so.”

Her speech sparked applause among opposition councillors.

Labour’s Michael Graveston argued for a council tax rise. He said: “Allocating £250,000 seems a bit lean for the Joiners’ Arms. We propose a 2.99 per cent council tax increase and would use money raised specifically for that project. It’s especially important for people in vulnerable circumstances – and for the benefit of the property itself.”

He also said council finances might appear healthy but a day-to-day revenue deficit was forecast in a few years. So raising council tax now would address that.

He added: “I don’t take council tax rises lightly. But a 2.99 per cent rise would be £5.10 per year for a Band D house. That’s less than 10p a week.”

Lib-Dem Mark Sutcliffe agreed, saying: “Less well-off families are more likely to depend on properly-funded council projects and benefit from projects like this. The Tories’ obsession with austerity has left us with chronically under-funded services. The Ribble Valley deserves and expects better.”

Lib-Dem Mary Robinson added: “We’ve put bits of money, here and there, into the Joiner’s Arms. But if we can do something better, we should. Regarding council tax, I live in a band B house. In Clitheroe, Band B and C houses cover the vast majority of the town so many people wouldn’t even pay the £5 extra.”

‘JOHNNY-COME-LATELYS’

A Ribble Valley full council meetingplaceholder image
A Ribble Valley full council meeting | Robbie MacDonald/LDRS

But Conservative Kevin Horkin said: “I’m disappointed with this proposal because these topics had a good airing in meetings earlier this year. The opposition is hell-bent on increasing residents’ council tax at this difficult time.

“If it wasn’t for Conservative rule here over the past 10 years, we’d have seen rise-after-rise. But we have got good reserves in the bank because we have been prudent.”

“It’s easy for Johnny-come-latelys to say ‘raise the council tax’. But that’s student politics. I’d like opposition councillors to come out with me to ask residents about council tax.”

Looking ahead to Lancashire council reforms due in 2028, he added: “Labour wants to start increasing taxes now so there’s no huge surprise when the new, gargantuan authorities bring massive tax rises.”

Fellow Conservative Stuart Hirst said: “This is not the council’s money. This is residents’ money. That means we have to act prudently and only take what we need. People argue a Ribble Valley council tax rise would be tiny compared to the county council’s. But the principle still stands.”

Conservative Simon Hore, the council leader, said he was concerned with Labour’s late amendment. He said: “Budget plans have gone through previous meetings, when we agreed not to raise council tax. We also agreed to £250,000 for the Joiners’ Arms and £250,000 for Clitheroe Market

“The Joiners Arms is emergency accommodation, not affordable housing. I have heard Coun Ray’s speech tonight and agree about its refurbishment, which is why it’s in the budget. But I’m not in favour of increasing council tax. And we are not alone in freezing our tax. Labour-run Hyndburn and Chorley are not increasing theirs'”

He also said there were plans for affordable apartments at Waterloo House in Clitheroe.

But Progressive Liberal Mark French said: “I’m not a Johnny-come-lately. I’ve been on the council 11 years. Last year, officers had concerns when council tax was frozen then. Now, I’m concerned that not raising council tax once again will have a knock-on effect in future. ”

And regarding Labour’s ‘late’ amendment, Green Coun Malcolm Peplow claimed the Conservatives were hypocrites because council officers and a councillors’ working group had recommended a council tax rise in talks. But the Conservatives then advocated a freeze, against earlier advice.

But the Conservatives won enough votes. with some independents. to freeze the council tax.

News you can trust since 1886
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice