Accusations over planning system ‘failings’ and burial pit fears as controversial homes plan decided
A former MP has made accusations of ‘failings’ and ‘evidence gaps’ in the assessment of a controversial plan for 200 homes near a Lancaster village, including potential contamination risks from a foot-and-mouth disease animal burial pit nearby.
David Morris, ex-Conservative MP for Morecambe, queried Lancaster City Council’s assessment of the application by Wrenman Strategic Land, for homes on land west of Slyne Road. And he criticised the site’s treatment as less important ‘grey belt’ land rather than green belt.
However, council planning officers insisted the plan was properly considered against a backdrop which includes new government ambitions to get more houses built on land considered ‘grey belt’.


Ultimately, the application was refused by councillors, against the officers’ advice to approve it. The plan prompted hundreds of objections and many residents attended the council planning meeting this week, where more than 10 objectors spoke.
There, Mr Morris said there had been a ‘failure of due diligence’ and ‘unsound procedures’ in the council’s assessment. In particular, he claimed:
- There was ‘no site-specific investigation’ of a burial pit of animals from the 1965 foot-and-mouth disease outbreak on land nearby. Instead, the application relied on ‘generic case study information’ from the 2001 foot-and-mouth outbreak.
- ‘Reclassifying’ the Slyne Road farmland as ‘grey belt’ rather than green belt by planning officers was a ‘misrepresentation’ and the grey belt policy was still under consultation by the government until March.
- The Slyne Road application failed to meet ‘basic evidence standards’.
Other objectors who spoke included Peter Yates of Carnforth, Barrie Wells, the owner of Slyne Hall; Reform county councillor Russell Walsh, Lesley Bryan of Torrisholme, Jules Farrer from the Friends of Lapwing Fields Green Space group, Steve Bryan of Torrisholme, Gill McKechnie from Bolton-le-Sands, Heather Wells of Slyne-with-Hest, Lisa Hignett from Hest Bank and Peter Wood from Bolton-le-Sands.
Peter Yates told the meeting: “This is beautiful countryside and pristine green belt land. It should not be built on. It is not the grey belt. I am 79 years old and have known those fields since I was a boy. For 70 years or so, that land has never been touched.”
.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

Barry Wells, from Slyne Hall, said: “This plan would totally destroy beautiful green open space for no public benefit whatsoever. Many of us also believe the planning committee has not gone into enough detail about the heritage aspects of this plan, including the impact of new homes on Slyne Hall.”
SUPPORTERS
However, Laurie Lane, from Lane Town Planning, supported the Wrenman application. He said: “This complies with guidance and ‘golden rules’ for allowing developments with affordable homes which would be a huge public benefit.”
Regarding concerns about pressures on local schools from extra homes, he said: “Lancashire County Council says primary schools would be able to accommodate children from the new homes in future.”
On the impact on nature, he said: “While there are some concerns, reports show other sites are more important for birds. Overall, any harm caused by this development would not outweigh the public benefit of new homes.”
Council planning officers said they recognised the application had raised strong feelings. But they believed there were no strong reasons to refuse it. The benefits of housing would outweigh any harm. They also said councillors had the right to take a different view but would need clear reasons to refuse it.
Conservative Coun Keith Budden emphasised his respect for planning officers but he was ‘unconvinced’ by their treatment of the fields as ‘grey belt’ and their ‘departure’ from treating it as green belt.
He said: “Green belt or grey belt labels should not be changed by a few well-meaning people in the office, for us to rubber stamp. I think we should refuse this plan for green belt reasons.”


Preventing urban sprawl and the lack of very special circumstances to justify building on green belt land were suggested reasons.
However, officers said every site was considered individually including in the green belt. For various reasons, the Slyne Road fields were viewed by officers as grey belt. Overall, they said the green belt was designed to maintain space between major built-up areas, such as Lancaster and Morecambe, rather than automatically block any village development. Developments at villages with local services and transport links were often more-sustainable than smaller, remote villages.
Also, officers said a contamination report found no areas of concern and the animal burial pit is south of the proposed development land. Other authorities had no contamination concerns.
But Green Coun Tom Fish said: “This plan proposes the minimum amount of affordable housing seen as acceptable. But what is called ‘affordable’ is, in reality, still not really affordable, especially to rent.
“Also, the links for cycles and walkers are poor. Cyclists would have to go a mile up the road to get onto the canal tow-path because the nearest canal bridge has steps.
“Young people need more consideration too. They like to walk or cycle to work or college. But people in these new homes would be overwhelmingly reliant on cars.”
However, Labour’s Catherine Potter supported the plan. She said: “We desperately need more homes and affordable homes. If not here, where? This site is close to the A6 and local services with good connections. It is not really open countryside. Yes, this district is blessed with open countryside – but this site is not that.
“I deeply empathise with neighbours who object but this is currently agricultural land with zero public access. This housing plan would also create public open space for all residents to enjoy and access to the canal. “
Lib Dem Alan Greenwell also said affordable housing was needed.
But in a vote, the majority of councillors refused the plan.
Speaking afterwards, resident Glenn Fothergill, from Bolton le Sands, said: “I was expecting the plan to be approved so I’m delighted that common sense seems to have prevailed. It’s a big relief for everyone.”
And Peter Wood said: “I’m pleased at the decision. I felt councillors were really put on the spot in having to decide this and they listened to the arguments from all sides.”
Lancaster City Council has been approached for further comment.