"Witch hunt": former Lancashire county swimmer forced to end private lessons at home

A former Lancashire county swimmer who has prompted objections with a planning wrangle over holding commercial swimming lessons at her home, says she has been forced to use public pools instead.

Sarah Makin runs the Above Surface Swim School and has used her home pool at Far Brex Farm, Coal Pit Lane, near Whitwell Bottom, Rossendale for the past six years but this use has been the focus of planning applications and appeals involving Rossendale Council and the national Planning Inspectorate.

Now, she says it’s ‘sad’ that her commercial lessons at home have had to end.

She said she renovated the pool some years ago, which had been used for other purposes like storage in the past.

Sara said: “I live on a farm which is reached by a lane. At the opposite end, there’s a cluster of neighbiours’ homes which, I feel, are not effected by the lessons. But there’s been on a bit of witch hunt. Between them and the authorities, I’ve been told I cannot run commercial lessons at home.

“It’s mind-blowing. I don’t understand that mentality. I thought I was doing something good for the borough. But a few other people don’t seem to get my way of thinking. It seems like a NIMBY mentality.

“Some neighbours had issues with parents bringing their kids in cars for swimming lessons, with cars going up and down the lane. So I asked parents to arrange car-share, so there were less cars. And the swimming lessons were restricted to certain days and times.

“It’s sad because I hold lessons for children, including many neuro-diverse children, who struggle with big pool environments. I now hire time at other pools at Whitworth and Burnley, and run classes there.

“But the Burnley situation might change. I’m currently using St Peter’s Leisure Centre but that arrangement’s going to end after Christmas. I’m also using Whitworth Leisure Centre in Rossendale, which is now run by a community co-operative.

“There is also Castleton baths in Rochdale. But going to other places means travel costs and paying rental to hire the pools. It impacts on business.”

Sarah Makin, who runs the Above Surface Swim School, can no longer use her personal pool in Rossendale for lessons.placeholder image
Sarah Makin, who runs the Above Surface Swim School, can no longer use her personal pool in Rossendale for lessons. | LDR

Sarahsaid Rossendale Council environmental health officers had visited her home and found no issues but planning permission and traffic were the problems.

She he said friends and family would still visit her home and use the pool.

On the availability of pools and swimming lessons generally, the swimmer said: “There are not enough pools or good teachers. I fear we’re failing children today. And I think the way many typical swimming lessons are run is prehistoric.

“Pools could get more kids and be more cost-effective if things were done differently. But typical pay for staff is poor, I believe, with big organisations. They typically pay something like £11 or £15 an hour for staff. We’re not getting the cream of the crop, if we have these types of arrangements.

Asked is she could find employment as a teacher at other pools, Sarah said: “I passed my teacher training aged 18. I’m 53 now and will become a grandparent soon. Teaching is not something I would do now. But if I was 30 years younger, definitely.

“With my lessons, my focus os on teaching children to swim, a life-saving skill. I want to stop children drowning. If one or two become national swimmers, that’s fabulous. But that’s not my main motive. ”

Regarding the planning system, in 2022 Mrs Makin gained permission for her home lessons in an appeal against Rossendale Council.

She was allowed to change the use of her pool, from a private pool to a commercial pool but there was a condition limiting this for a temporary two years.

Later in a second appeal in 2024, she tried to have the two-year period removed and a planning inspector visited her site in early 2025.

This year, planning inspector H Senior issued his decision and dismissed her appeal.

The inspector wrote: “The main issue is whether granting permanent planning permission for using a private pool as a commercial pool is appropriate, having regard to the [council’s] development plan and other considerations.”

In one written section, he said Mrs Makin’s lessons generated ‘up to 30 car trips per day’. There may be occasions when pupils arrived together but he had seen no substantive evidence.

Whilst there was no substantive evidence of accidents or congestion on Coal Pit Lane, due partly to the 30-minute changeover condition, the lane’s use could not be controlled to only the swimming pool users.

The lane was also a bridleway and footpath route and access to a number of homes. Users could be walkers, horse riders and cyclists as well as residents and deliveries. The home pool is located in an unsustainable location and accessed via a narrow unadopted road, he said.

He acknowledge Mrs Makin’s personal circumstances, including that she is aqualified swimming teacher and been nominated for business awards, and he accepted swimming is a vital life skill. However, dismissing Mrs Makin’s appeal was ‘proportionate and necessary’ to ensuring significant harm was not caused and to protect the public.

News you can trust since 1886
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice