Leyland prisoner died in HMP Garth cell fire after 'fire alarm' failure

Benjamin Fitzsimmons, 47, died after a fire broke out inside his cell at the high-security Leyland prison...

A prisoner died in a cell fire at a Lancashire jail after a fire alarm reportedly failed to activate, according to a damning new report that raises concerns about safety across the UK’s prison estate.

Benjamin Fitzsimmons, 47, died at HMP Garth, the Category B men's high-security prison in Ulnes Walton, Leyland, on September 24.

HMP Garth in Ulnes Walton near Leylandplaceholder image
HMP Garth in Ulnes Walton near Leyland

The Prisons and Probation Ombudsman is investigating his death and the Independent Monitoring Boards (IMBs), which oversee prisons in England and Wales, highlighted his death in a recent report as evidence of how ageing and deteriorating buildings are putting inmates at risk.

The IMB, made up of a thousand unpaid volunteers, provides statutory, independent oversight, monitoring the treatment and care of prisoners and detainees across England and Wales.

In its latest annual review, the watchdog said: "At HMP Garth, a prisoner tragically died in a cell fire after the alarm apparently failed to sound. Boards had acute concerns about fire safety across the estate, including the inadequacy of evacuation arrangements for those with mobility issues, and faulty fire alarms."

The IMBs said the incident reflects wider concerns over malfunctioning fire alarms and other safety failings which are putting inmates at risk in the nation’s prisons.

The review also said self-inflicted deaths were a key concern in men's prisons and said HMP Garth was among "cluster sites" where they were "occurring at an alarming frequency".

A 39-year-old man was arrested after a drone was seen flying over the walls of HMP Garth near Leyland on Tuesday nightplaceholder image
A 39-year-old man was arrested after a drone was seen flying over the walls of HMP Garth near Leyland on Tuesday night | Wiki

Jane Leech MBE, interim national chair of the IMB, painted a bleak picture of the system, describing the UK’s prisons as a "crumbling estate" struggling under "relentless population pressures”.

The death at HMP Garth in Leyland, she said, was a fatal example of how the UK prison estate’s “deteriorating buildings are exposing prisoners to inhumane conditions”

She said: “Poor conditions, limited regimes and unsafe environments damage mental and physical wellbeing, undermine rehabilitation, and erode dignity. They also affect public safety, the likelihood of reoffending, staff retention, and trust in the justice system."

Andrea Coomber, chief executive of the Howard League for Penal Reform, said the report exposed the stark contrast between political promises and the harsh reality of conditions behind bars.

Don’t miss the stories shaping Lancashire. Sign up to our free breaking newsletter

"The report reveals the gulf between the rhetoric we hear in Westminster and the reality we see in overwhelmed and under-resourced jails up and down the country," she said.

The findings add to growing scrutiny of the condition of Britain's prisons, with campaigners and watchdogs repeatedly warning that overcrowding, ageing infrastructure and staff shortages are placing both prisoners and employees at risk.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1886
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice