'I seem to get things wrong now' Lancashire man felled with a single punch | Preston Crown Court
How a single punch left one man with serious brain damage while his assailant narrowly avoids jail. Lancashire Post reporting exclusively from Preston Crown Court
A thug who caused serious brain injuries to a man with a single punch outside a nightclub has been spared a jail term.
.jpeg?crop=3:2,smart&trim=&width=640&quality=65)

Preston Crown Court heard Eddie McDonagh felled his victim without warning causing him to hit his head on the pavement.
The man was rushed to hospital with a fractured skull and a bleed on the brain. Months later he was still said to be suffering from memory issues and problems with speech, taste and smell.
McDonagh pleaded guilty to assault causing actual bodily harm and was given a 16-week prison sentence suspended for 12 months.
The court was told the 24-year-old had originally pleaded not guilty to a more serious charge, claiming it was self-defence, but had admitted the lesser offence of ABH assault when it was offered by the prosecution as an alternative on the day his trial was due to begin.
It was claimed the victim had convictions for violence and had earlier punched McDonagh after being ejected from the club for causing trouble. He had also declined to co-operate with police investigating the assault which put him in hospital.
Recorder Anna Price heard that McDonagh, of Charter Street, Accrington, and the victim were not known to each other until the night they clashed outside the Dodge Nightclub in Warner Street, Accrington.
In the early hours of June 15, 2024 McDonagh was on a night out with his wife and mother-in-law. During the evening issues arose and the victim was ejected from club.
At about 3:15am there was an altercation as McDonagh’s wife and mother-in-law tried to get in a taxi, leading to the victim running towards him and hitting him in the face causing him to fall the ground.
A short while later both men were standing outside the venue when, without warning, McDonagh swung a punch which caught his opponent in the face and knocked him backwards, causing him to hit his head “full force” on the pavement.
Paramedics responding to another incident nearby were diverted to the scene and rushed the unconscious man as a “major trauma call” to the Royal Preston Hospital which specialises in serious head injuries. Doctors found he had a bleed on the brain, a fracture to the back of the skull and several other significant brain injuries.
McDonagh left the scene of the attack, but police managed to track him on CCTV to a travellers’ caravan park in Charter Street, Accrington. They visited the site and showed residents images of the man they were looking for.
Five days later a solicitor acting on behalf of McDonagh told officers he wanted to hand himself in. When he arrived at the police station he had trimmed his beard and had a haircut and answered “no comment” to all questions.
The court heard a personal impact statement from the victim read out in which he said after the assault he had suffered a lot of headaches, his memory seemed to be affected, he sometimes fluffed his words and admitted: “I seem to get things wrong now, like I called the washing machine the fridge yesterday.”
His smell and taste senses had been affected and could only really tase food if it was “a strong spicey meal like curry”. He had returned to hospital five months after the attack because he was experiencing tingling in his lips and “excruciating” pain in his head but had been told that was normal after serious head injuries.
Efforts by police to find out how he was now – almost two years after the injuries were inflicted – had not brought a response from him, said police.
Barrister Jo Shepherd, defending, said that the victim had been “causing some problems” within the club itself earlier that night. “That doesn’t excuse in any way what he (McDonagh) did, but it might explain something which was “clearly out of character” for him.”
He had no previous convictions, yet the victim had several violent matters on his record and had been in court just two months after the attack on him.
He had been claiming “self-defence” when faced with the more serious charge but had been offered ABH assault on the day of his trial and had decided to take it.
“Mr McDonagh is genuinely remorseful,” she added. “It has led him to make changes to the way he conducts his social life and reducing his alcohol intake. He is taking steps to avoid going out to areas where there is social interaction or confrontation.”
Recorder Price said there had been an issue between McDonagh and the other man earlier in the evening and the victim “caused problems which led to him being ejected from the nightclub.
“That is no excuse. Standing next to him and without any warning you punched him in the face and he fell backwards and banged his head on the pavement and lost consciousness.
“Having watch the video (CCTV of the assault) and taking into account his injuries this crosses the threshold and only a sentence of custody is justified.
“You have expressed remorse and I accept you are sorry for the way you acted on that night. I accept there is a realistic prospect of rehabilitation. You don’t present a risk of harm. Taking all the facts into account I feel I can suspend the sentence.”
In addition to the 16-week suspended sentence McDonagh was also ordered to complete 20 rehabilitation activity days.