Rail chaos: Chorley MP Sir Lindsay Hoyle grills Transport Secretary Chris Grayling

Transport Secretary Chris Grayling has faced a 45-minute grilling at the hands of Chorley MP Sir Lindsay Hoyle over the Northern rail fiasco.

Wednesday, 6th June 2018, 10:53 pm
Updated Tuesday, 19th June 2018, 6:06 pm
Sir Lindsay Hoyle has spoken to Chris Grayling on the rail timetable chaos

And the Minister was left in no doubt about the anger of passengers across the North of England following days of cancelled or delayed trains.

“In fairness to him he listened,” said Sir Lindsay, Deputy Speaker of the Commons. “He wanted to hear my views, so I told him straight.

“I asked him why we have not taken the franchise off Northern. This company seems incapable of running a service, so in my view we should take it off them.”

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

Sir Lindsay Hoyle has spoken to Chris Grayling on the rail timetable chaos

More than 60 MPs whose constituents have been badly hit by the Northern timetable turmoil demanded to see the Minister after he finally announced on Monday there would be compensation for commuters and an inquiry into what has gone wrong.

Only a handful managed to see him, with Sir Lindsay getting “the best part of three-quarters of an hour.”

“He came to my office,” he said. “We went through the issues and what can be done.

“Let’s face it, this is complete chaos. We have got to get more trains in.

Passengers waiting for a train

“They (Northern) just keep changing the timetable to the lowest possible level, so at some point it will work. But that doesn’t help people who rely on the train network to get to work, school and university.

“I told him the problems facing my constituents in Chorley. It is having a major impact on the travelling public.

“And I said ‘if you think it’s bad now, what is it going to be like at the peak tourism period?’ Extra demand will put even more pressure on the trains.

“We had a very thorough discussion. But in the end we won’t sort this problem out unless we take some sort of drastic action.

The guides got to Scarborough eventually

“Members on all sides of the House are demanding just what I am demanding. We want him to take action.

“It’s up to him if he wants to listen. But the bottom line is we have to resolve this issue and fast.”

‘We’re all fed up with them blaming each other’

Among the queue of MPs lining up to demand answers from bosses from rail operator Northern and Network Rail was Lancashire’s Gordon Marsden.Mr Marsden, who represents Blackpool South, quizzed Northern’s regional director, Sharon Keith, about the state of services in the county.He told the Post: “I told both Northern and Network Rail that we were all fed up of them basically blaming each other for the problems.“What we need is straight forward information on what is happening now, specifically about why it is that the Blackpool South line was singled out for strong cuts given that there was only a hourly service there anyway and why it is that, on top of that, there have been further cancellations of trains on that route despite the reduced timetable? “I asked for information on that within the next 48 hours otherwise I said I would be tabling Parliamentary Questions.”He also raised concerns over the fact rail replacement buses are not fully accessible for disabled people.He added: “She confirmed that the replacement buses would still be in use until the end of June at least. “I again asked for clarity on the disabled access within 48 hours.”

Join petition

This week the Post joined forces with a host of other titles across the North to demand action to fix our broken railways.You can add your voice to the call for our Government to step in give the region the power it needs to get our trains back on track by signing the petition.To sign, visit: Change.org

What’s it like for commuters?

Rob Lowe (pictured), from Lancaster, uses the trains to get to work and “cannot bear it”.He said: “I think like a lot of rail-users at the moment who have some flexibility, then I’ve been trying to keep my travel down to a minimum. The Northern rail services have been very unreliable. My journey time has increased by 25 per cent every day because of the lack of a direct service to Manchester Oxford Road.l Katie Twomey, a lecturer at the University of Manchester, commutes to work and described the current situation as “ incredibly stressful and extremely tiring”.She said: “I’ve been commuting from Lancaster to Manchester since September 2017. The Northern service has always been unreliable, with late trains and cancellations commonplace.“However since the introduction of the new timetables in May, the service is so unreliable my commute is frequently five or more hours a day.“I have not managed to catch a single on-time Northern service in the past month.“Problems with dangerous overcrowding have worsened due to the increases in cancellations - the fact that the majority of these are due to a lack of staff - presumably a lack of planning prior to the implementation of the new timetables - is appalling.“I know some of my fellow passengers are at risk of losing their jobs because they are unable to get to work on time, if at all, and several I have spoken to are considering moving away from Lancaster because the rail service is so ineffective.“This is damaging our local economy and is a huge disincentive for people to move here, not to mention the impact the inability to travel has on the tourist economy. “I’m tired of seeing people in tears on platforms - myself sometimes included - from the sheer frustration caused by this shambolic service.“Northern should be stripped of their franchise: they have proven themselves incapable of managing a functioning service.”

‘Five hours of hell’ on a trip to Scarborough

Emma Maudsley organised a trip to Scarborough for a group of girl guides.She described ‘five hours of hell’ as the chaos on the railway meant the train they were booked onto got cancelled, forcing the group of 15 to take an alternative, crowded service.She told the Post: “The train to Manchester was packed - we had to split into 3 groups just to get on and most of us stood the whole way.“It was a miracle I could keep sight of the girls in my group.”“Our train to York was marginally less packed but at Leeds it filled with racegoers all out for a good time and many drinking alcohol. We missed our connection at York and finally arrived into Scarborough an hour behind schedule.”